I recently paid off the loan on my car and had to have the lien removed on my car’s title. Unlike in the US, where that is a transaction between the lienholding financial institution and the DMV, with the owner being a passive participant who is mailed the updated title at the end, in India you are required to collect a dues cleared certificate from the lienholder and apply for a removal of hypothecation at the RTO.

I figured this was a pretty simple step and ignored the oft-recommended approach of enlisting an agent for this purpose. A few of my previous experiences with the RTO had been at the Koramangla Center, and while the place is chaotically crowded and miserly on providing any clear instructions, I had been able to navigate it in the past, and found it not too bad. The car had been registered at the Kasturinagar RTO (KA-03) though, and that’s where I had to go. I figured, how different could it be it to the Koramangla one?

Let’s cut to the end - it was not the same. It took me a good four months and three separate visits before I had the updated RC card in my hands. The differences started with the office itself. Koramangla is laid out like a big hall with the officials behind cubicles and desks. Not so for Kasturinagar, no sir. The office is off bounds to you. You approach windows in the wall of the office, behind which the clerks are perched. Pray it’s not raining or hot.

Screen Shot 2023-04-19 at 8.48.13 PM.png

These windows are little more than portholes, about a foot-square either way. Notice also the lack of any real signs around the windows save for a number. Without crowd control or line discipline, what you have is a bunch of people hanging around these tiny windows, making it impossible to even figure out if the window is attended - which they’re often not - without jostling to the front of that crowd. You don't move with the queue. Instead, a crowd just mills around the window and gets added to or subtracted from. You shout your questions, or the clerk calls out your name and you wrangle your way to the front of the window. As for what you do when you get to the window -

imagine if you had to write an algorithm for the process. There’s a login step, maybe with 2-factor authentication, selecting the appropriate form, filling it out, attaching the necessary documentation, submitting the form, a validator running on the data and checking if everything’s proper, a detour to a payments page, the business with receiving and putting in an OTP, back to the site, and it’s done. At the end, a confirmation email or SMS gets sent out.

algorithms-hire-humans-1588687684 (1).jpg

That’s a pretty close approximation of how it works IRL at the RTO.

Since the windows are numbered but not labeled, except for one that helpfully informs you is for information; nor are the windows dedicated to a single task, you line up at the information window to ask what the process is. They direct you

𝕿o a window where you pick up the form. You fill it out and go

𝕿o a window where they check if your supporting documents are proper. If they deem so, they mark your application with a literal stamp of approval. (In my case, I found out the application needed to be ensconced in an approved folder that had to be bought, along with an approved self-addressed stamped envelope, from an approved vendor; so it was off to a nearby shop to buy them and head back to the window). Next you head

𝕿o the cashier window to pay the fee.